as someone who has faithfully followed all 7 seasons of Survivor, here's my ideal cast list for All Stars Survivor:

Season 1 (Pulau Tiga):
Richard--interesting to see if this regaled Granddaddy of Survivor can hold up against stiff competition
Susan--her tirade at Tribal Council is still one of my most memorable memories from Survivor
Colleen--first sweetie-pie that played Survivor. but isn't a pushover. need i say more?
Greg--weirdo but not creepy weird like Matthew (Amazon). kinda endearing to watch once you get used to his mannerisms

Season 2 (Outback):
Jerri--Finest bitch ever! a huge void would be left unfilled if she werent playing
Elizabeth--Only player that made me go "Awwwwww...." every time i heard her speak
Jeff--he would have been a terrific villain if he weren't voted out so early
Colby--strongest player at Outback. swept almost all the challenges. curious to see whether he can monopolise all the challenges again
Tina--cos she isn't so deserving since Colby practically gave her the $$$$. to see how far she can go this time. i think she has more in her than she had let on during Outback though

Season 3 (Africa):
Ethan--he won by being a nice guy. Can that strategy ever be repeated at Survivor?

Season 4 (Marquesas):
Kathy--bestowed the honour of the first power-broker. from no allies to third position (with no thanks to evil bitch vercepia). how can she not be there?
Gina--I picked her over Rob, the Godfather because i was crushed when i saw her voted off. she might have done better this time round.

Season 5 (Thailand):
Shii Ann--do us Asians proud!

Season 6 (Amazon):
Rob Cesternino --personally, i think he's the best player of all time. how can he not be there??!!
Christy--first Deaf contestant. a bit clueless at playing the game but boy, do i root for her!
Jenna--from spolit brat to commendable winner. let's hope she is as interesting to watch during All-Stars

Season 7 (Pearl Islands):
Rupbert--Eeeeewwww. but he is so fun to hate!
Sandra--okay, so she isn't so cleverly devious as i have originally hoped. but i like her brutal honesty, her sneakiness when playing the game, her splendid performance at Final Tribal Council, her pettiness even

**************************
which is why i thought some choices for All-Stars are bizarre. Big Tom, Rudy, Alicia, Rob the Godfather i'm fine with but Jenna Lewis? Amber the Fillipino maid? Lex the neurotic kan-cheong spider?